Welcome to The Old Bag of Nails
The Old Bag of Nails, located at 4661 E Broad St, Whitehall, OH, captures the essence of comfort food in a welcoming atmosphere. Known for its generous portions and diverse menu, highlights include their peel-your-own shrimp and uniquely prepared fish hooks, which offer a delightful twist on traditional favorites. Diners rave about the attentive service, with staff like Madison and Ashley ensuring a memorable experience. With a spacious setting, plentiful parking, and a relaxed vibe, it's no wonder regulars, like Myra, return weekly for dishes such as the chicken Cobb salad and hearty chili. This establishment is a true gem in the community.
The Old Bag of Nails: Reviews & Ratings
Had the whole family in for dinner which was a total of 8 people, too much food to explain but I ordered the chili with corn bread, peel your own shrimp, and the nacho platter overall our waitress Madison was very nice, worked with all of us for a total of 8 people ordering different things, very patient and got our food to us in a timely manner. The shrimp was great! Nacho on the okay side i should've added the chicken but next time! Chili was good but I'm a jiffy cornbread girl and didn't really find interest in theirs. Thanks for having us and we will be back.
Great time great food Great waitstaff! Hope this one stays nice seems more open than the others. Second time in a week! Not disappointed at all. We had chicken tenders, fish and chips and salmon. All prepared perfectly.
Ashley was our server- she was great! Mushrooms were very good Hubby had blackened fish & I had half sized spinach salad! Very tasty! Nice listening music Restaurant was very spacious & clean! Plenty of parking out front of Old Bag.
The new Old bag of nails in whitehall. I took my girlfriend out for a long over do birthday dinner, she wanted to go here because she likes the fish hooks. It's the cod fish prepared like tenders but called fish hooks. They came so amazing fresh & hot with steak fries. We had ordered an appetizer the battered mushrooms which I'm not a fan of mushrooms but these were delicious. Our waiter Carson was amazing, he chatted with us & did the most as our waiter. I really enjoyed him. A great evening with great food. Oh it was so much food.
Come here about once a week. No matter how busy always terrific service. Clean not too noisy. Lots of tvs and. Oaths have their own tvs. Lots of variety not just the amazing fish and chips. Burgers and salads yum. My go to is the chicken Cobb salad with the balsamic vinaigrette on the side. Love that dressing. I also get it without the bacon and pickled onions - personal preference. What you get is a humongous salad jam packed with protein - egg,grilled chicken and feta.
I love this place. The food is bomb and all the servers are super cute and friendly. The food is always prepared perfectly. I love how you can see they put efforts in quality and presentation. Inside this place is always immaculately clean. I thoroughly enjoy their happy hour and frequent this place because they are the best bar around both local and in the whole city. This place is great
Wednesday is all you can eat shrimp... yummy!!! They have 4 different choices to choose from and I tried 3 out of the 4 options . My server was awesome!!!
Craving seafood, we decided to drop by Old Bag of Nails. We were seated right away and quickly received our drinks. I chose a tall, frothy Guinness, while my wife went for a cranberry Kentucky mule. Our order was taken very quickly, and the food arrived in just about 15 minutes, given it was a fairly light lunch crowd I opted for the Classic Fish and Chips, which featured two crispy British-style Atlantic fillets that were absolutely delicious. The meal also came with seasoned steak fries and a sweet, tangy coleslaw—an excellent combination My wife had the seasonal lobster rolls off their winter menu served with kettle chips, and she said had the perfect balance of mayonnaise, butter, and lobster, all brought together by a lightly toasted New England roll Our server, Maddison, provided friendly and attentive service throughout the meal. We definitely look forward to returning soon!
Location
-
4661 E Broad St, Whitehall, OH 43213, United States Hotline: +1 614-655-2424
Welcome to The Old Bag of Nails, an intriguing spot nestled at 4661 E Broad St in Whitehall, OH. This establishment is not your typical restaurant; it is a vibrant destination where flavor, friendliness, and a laid-back atmosphere come together in perfect harmony. With a phone number of +1 614-655-2424 for easy inquiries, this eatery aims to create memorable dining experiences for every guest.
As you step into The Old Bag of Nails, you are greeted by a spacious environment filled with the buzz of happy diners and friendly waitstaff. Patrons frequently highlight the attentiveness of the team, exemplified by servers like Madison and Ashley, who have been lauded for their exceptional service. Whether accommodating a large family gathering or a romantic dinner, the staff's warmth and professionalism ensure a comfortable dining experience for all.
The menu at The Old Bag of Nails is a treasure trove of culinary delights. Reviewers rave about the diverse offerings, from the indulgent chili with cornbread to the peel-your-own shrimp, which showcases freshness and flavor. The nacho platter, while noted as needing an additional kick, still makes for a delightful appetizer worth exploring. Another standout is the fish hooks—cod fish tenders that offer a crispy, savory bite, perfect paired with steak fries. As Mz Lisa enjoyed, these unique dishes cater to various tastes and preferences, offering something for everyone.
Moreover, the restaurant excels in crafting both classic and innovative dishes. Customers have raved about the chicken tenders and fish and chips, highlighting the careful preparation that ensures each plate is served at the peak of flavor. Even the salads, like the chicken Cobb, are tailored to satisfy; packed with proteins like grilled chicken and feta, they are as nutritious as they are delicious.
Beyond the food, The Old Bag of Nails commits to creating a pleasant dining atmosphere that combines good music, cleanliness, and ample parking—making it an accessible choice for anyone looking to enjoy a meal out. Whether you're catching a game on one of the many TVs or simply enjoying a relaxing dinner with friends or family, this restaurant radiates a vibe that invites you to stay longer and savor each moment.
Overall, The Old Bag of Nails stands out in the culinary landscape of Whitehall, offering a blend of delicious food, attentive service, and a welcoming atmosphere. It's no surprise that diners like Myra Weisman find themselves returning weekly, indicating that this gem of a restaurant is destined to become a staple in the community. Make your way to this charming locale and discover why so many are captivated by The Old Bag of Nails!